Thu 14 Sep 2006
Real Estate Fatwa
Posted by Marlow Harris under Middle East & Islam, Real Estate

Matt Carter made an interesting post on the Inman blog about Azerbaijan, a country situated on the Caspian Sea between Russia and Iran, that only recently regained its independence after the 1991 breakup of the Soviet Union. He noted that their banks have just now began to offer home mortgages and so far, they’ve issued 86 loans, with interest rates averaging 10.2 percent.
Why is this so interesting? Because the country of Azerbaijan is 93.4% Muslim. And Islam forbids the paying of interest, as it violates a teaching of Allah. What is specifically Shari’ah (forbidden) is taking interest, giving it, writing it, and being a witness to its contract. Azerbaijan’s official stance has been that it is a secular state. This is the first indication that it is really moving in that direction.
Because the paying of interest is Shari’ah, most people in Islamic countries rent or have managed to save enough money to pay cash for a home. They have also devised an unsual paper manipulation to pay more for a house than it is worth and then buy it on time but not paying interest, just paying more and for longer than they would if they paid cash for it.
Can a Muslim be a real estate agent? Yes, if they have nothing to do with the paying or taking of interest. Which, of course, is very difficult in Western countries.
According to Mufti Monzer Kahf, a job of real estate agent is allowed for a cash-only sale, with no financing or bank mortgage.
He states:
In the Name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful.
All praise and thanks are due to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon His Messenger.Being a real estate agent for a certain company is permissible as long as the agent avoids writing an application for a forbidden interest-based loan and avoids selling stolen property. What applies to real estate also applies to refering others to the same real estate company for the purpose of buying and selling.
Dr. Monzer Kahf, a prominent economist, counselor and mufti states the following:
Working as a real estate agent or owner of an agency is permissible because the main line of business is helping people buy and sell real estate properties. What is prohibited in the Shari’ah is taking interest, giving it, writing it, and being a witness to its contract. It is not forbidden to help people buy and sell properties. Of course, two things are haram: to write an application for forbidden interest-based loan (a buyer may be under conditions of necessity and hence its loan may not be forbidden); and to help sell stolen property. These must be avoided by any agent, whether in real estate or other businesses.
The same applies to the referral because in referral you are also helping in buying and selling, and it is none of your business how the buyer is going to finance the purchase or whether the other agent is going to help in writing the loan application; you are not required to investigate what other people (agent or buyer) are going to do or how they are going to proceed in their relationships.
Thus, in both cases your commission is halal, in sha’ Allah.
Having clarified the above, I would like to add that in referral there is another point that must be clear: When you refer a friend who comes to you on the basis of trust and confidence and you refer him or her and take commission, the referred friend should know that in referring him or her to that specific agent you will get a commission; if he or she does not know that and takes your advice as a friendly trusted advice, such a commission is deserved to the friend not to you. You can’t be a paid adviser without the recipient of the advice knowing that you are paid, that is, that you have an interest in this advice.
I think this is all pretty interesting, especially in light of encouraging home ownership for minorities in the U.S..
Islam Online - Fatwa on being a Real Estate Agent
Niche banks find growth in Muslim market
Specialized services for Islamic communities help local lenders expand. Big banks not far behind.
Fulfilling the American Dream: Hard-Working Families Realize Home Ownership Dreams
6 Responses to “ Real Estate Fatwa ”
Comments:
Trackbacks & Pingbacks:
-
Pingback from Friday morning real estate links . . . | BloodhoundBlog | The weblog of BloodhoundRealty.com in Phoenix, Arizona
September 15th, 2006 at 7:53 am[...] Marlow Harris has a fascinating post on the barriers faced by Muslim buyers and real estate agents. Not to get too philosophical, but this actually ties in with Pope Benedict’s remarks earlier this week: Where Judaism and Christianity each represent measured compromises with Greek culture, Islam is in certain respects an anti-Hellenistic counter-revolution. (I can do this at a much more fundamental level, but you have to buy me beer.) [...]














September 22nd, 2006 at 4:59 pm
Wow … I totally missed the connection between Islam and interest rates. I just thought it was strange that they’d been getting by without mortgages all this time, and started thinking we really take some aspects of our society for granted.
I know “usury” was also a big issue with Christiantiy — back in the days of Jesus anyway — which the Western world seems to have left behind…
My guess is there are underground or informal systems of borrowing money in societies where charging interest is prohibited.
September 22nd, 2006 at 5:05 pm
Like the one you describe in your post!
September 22nd, 2006 at 5:32 pm
This particular subject is indicative of the huge cultural chasm between our two societies. Our banking system, real estate ownership, the stock market…. all of these things that make our capitalist society wealthy is out of reach of and forbidden by the Muslim world. Most of Islam does not have oil or other natural resources to provide riches to its people. And without these other options available, they don\’t have many ways to pull themselves out of poverty.
September 25th, 2006 at 9:39 pm
Islamic Finacing Company
Guidance Financial / Residential is an Islamic Financing company. We make replacement of your traditional Mortgage and Home Ownership possible by providing Sharia compliance financing. Please feel free to call me should you have any questions. United States Only!
Call or e-mail: Yama.Achikzai@guidancefinancial.com
September 8th, 2008 at 12:53 pm
I just wanted to make a note that the word Shari’ah is incorrectly used here. The word for forbidden in Islam is Haraam. Shari’ah is the law in which we abide by.